The Justices Side With Foster Children

The Supreme Court in Washington, June 8.


J. Scott Applewhite/Associated Press


As two single foster mothers of color, we have seen the harm caused by a foster system in crisis. We have also seen the hope and love created by faith-affirming foster agencies like Catholic Social Services. When Philadelphia decided in 2018 to shut down Catholic Social Services’ foster-care ministry because of its religious beliefs, we felt compelled to stand up for the agency. We are relieved and grateful that all nine justices of the Supreme Court ruled in our favor last week.

The foster and adoptive children we have cared for suffered serious abuse before coming to us. While we gave them all the love we could, we still needed the support of a village to help them overcome their past hardships and thrive. Catholic Social Services has been that village. Thanks to the tireless support of their staff—from late-night phone calls, Christmas presents delivered to our door, and support for various medical and special needs—our children are now on a path we could not have envisioned on our own.

We have seen other foster families burn out because they lacked such support. This type of motherhood isn’t always easy, but it is the most fulfilling ministry we could imagine, and we owe the joy of being able to provide for children in need to Catholic Social Services.

Faith-affirming foster care and adoption agencies are crucial in our community. Shutting them down because of what they believe would devastate already at-risk children by reducing the number of families able and willing to care for them. Some families choose to foster or adopt only if they can partner with an agency that shares their religious beliefs.

Allowing for a diverse array of foster agencies to serve the community is vital. Over 60% of the foster families Catholic Social Services certifies and supports are racial or ethnic minorities. Philadelphia desperately needs more families like these to care for children in need.

The Supreme Court’s unanimous decision is a victory for our own children, who witnessed their mothers go to court to defend their futures, and those of children just like them. They now know that the entire Supreme Court believes their future is worth protecting, and that what we have always taught them is true: they are worthy, they are seen and they are loved. We hope that this victory will send a message to Philadelphia’s foster children and families that they too are worthy, seen, and loved, and that they deserve the happiness of a family.

Ms. Fulton has fostered more than 40 children in 25 years. Ms. Simms-Busch is a former social worker and an adoptive mother of two. They were the named plaintiffs in Fulton v. City of Philadelphia.

Main Street: Ten years ago secular crusaders began their attempt to silence Jack Phillips for refusing to bake a cake for a same sex marriage. Today their intolerance continues over a cake celebrating gender transition. Image: Alliance Defending Freedom

Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

Appeared in the June 24, 2021, print edition.